Housing Perspective: August Case-Shiller Home Price Index
Tuesday, October 28th, 2008The S&P/Case-Shiller home price index is out today, showing a continuation of the downtrend in property values. Data from August — two full months before the financial crisis spun out of control — shows weakness across the country:
- Prices fell in August for the 25th consecutive month
- Prices in 10 major markets plunged a record 17.7% year over year
- The biggest declines in August were seen in San Francisco (-3.5%), Phoenix (-2.9%) and Las Vegas (-2.4%)
- The biggest declines year over year were seen in Phoenix (-30.7%), Las Vegas (-30.6%) and Miami (-28.1%)
- No metro area showed a price gain in the last 12 months.
- The best performing metro areas in the last 12 months were Dallas (-2.7%), Charlotte (-2.8%) and Boston (-4.7%).
Data continues to show that home prices are not approaching a bottom. Also, since contracts signed in the past month for home sales will not show up in the data until early next year (1-2 months escrow, 2 months lag in reporting), it’s pretty safe to assume data will be bleak for the foreseeable future. Calls for stabilization, especially after yesterday’s “better than expected” new home sales figures are premature.
The continued drop in home prices is further evidence that when considering buying a home in this market, one must be prepared to live there for at least five years. Trying to pick the bottom is a dicey proposition for everyone but the most savvy, well-capitalized investiors.
Most anyone who has bought a home in the past few months (or even years) has likely lost money on his or her investment. Add in the effect of leverage, and losses will be quite severe if homeowners are forced to sell.
It’s important to understand that the Case-Shiller index is not released by Realtors or Homebuilders, spinning data to try and persuade people it’s time to buy, or that Congress needs to increase handouts to prospective buyers. The data is simply produced to evidence the prevailing trends, in whichever direction they may be headed.
Finally, keep in mind that data from the “San Francisco” metro area, for example, includes data from the entire Bay Area. This means Oakland, Brentwood, Vallejo and other hard-hit cities are lumped together with Palo Alto, Hillsborough and other cities that have held up rather well. Attempts to make generalizations about homeowners in a particular area based on this data is misguided at best.